The Ohio State Buckeyes' pursuit of back-to-back national titles was abruptly halted on the final night of 2025, as they suffered a 24-14 loss to the Miami Hurricanes in the Cotton Bowl. This unexpected defeat marks the end of their season and initiates a nine-month period of introspection, aiming to identify and rectify the issues that led to this outcome before the 2026 season.
Several critical elements contributed to Ohio State's downfall, beginning with the challenges posed by a first-round bye. Despite last year's success, the bye proved to be a disadvantage, as teams receiving them in the 12-team College Football Playoff have consistently struggled in the quarterfinals, now holding an 0-5 record. Miami, having played recently, demonstrated superior early game rhythm, quickly establishing a 14-0 lead from which Ohio State could never fully recover. The offensive line's performance was another significant factor, allowing five sacks in the Cotton Bowl, a stark contrast to their season-long average. Quarterback Julian Sayin faced relentless pressure, hindering the team's offensive flow. Furthermore, special teams continued to be a persistent concern, highlighted by missed field goals and ineffective punting, contrasting sharply with Miami's well-executed special teams play. Head coach Ryan Day's decision to call offensive plays also drew scrutiny, suggesting that the demanding role may have spread his focus too thin, particularly in the absence of a dedicated offensive coordinator.
This season-ending loss underscores the importance of a holistic approach to team performance, where every unit, from the offensive line to special teams, operates at an elite level. It highlights the need for strategic coaching adjustments and a strong leadership presence to navigate the pressures of championship contention. The experience, while painful, offers a valuable opportunity for the Ohio State program to learn, adapt, and emerge stronger, reinforcing the resilience and determination essential for sustained success in collegiate athletics.